Wednesday 12 February 2020

Ground fault protection for non-grounded circuits


The non-grounded system is used in plants where power failure must be prevented for operation. Particularly, in many petrochemical plants, where explosive gas may catch fire owing to ground fault current and serious accidents may be caused, this system is used to reduce the ground fault current. On non-grounded circuits, the ground fault current is remarkably low even if one line falls down on the earth, and the current cannot be easily detected. Therefore, note that the protection effect of ELCB may not be expected only by installing it.

Circuit insulation detector (MEGMONITOR)
Mitsubishi circuit insulation detector, MEGMONITOR, has an excellent feature that enables constant monitoring of circuit without necessity of power interruption because it can monitor the whole electric circuit in the live state with lowvoltage small current and detect deterioration of insulation of circuit to the earth. Article 40 of interpretation for Guide Book of Electrical Equipment requires installation of ground fault circuit breakers on non-grounded circuits. In the past, appropriate devices for ground fault protection were not available, and the protection was provided by grounding capacitors and installing ELCB. However, to normally actuate ELCB, the capaci tor capaci ty should be considerably increased. This can generate sparks upon occurrence of ground fault and is unfavorable for the purpose of non-grounded circuits.

Fig. 9. 31 Explanation of operation 
MEGMONITOR can detect insulation deterioration corresponding to ground fault current of several mA and is suitable for detection of ground faults on non-grounded circuits. A ground fault circuit breaker can be easily configured by combining it with breakers. The operation is explained based on Fig. 9. 31. As an AC content, charging current flows through the earth capacitances (CA, CB and CC) on the circuit from the system power supply (commercial frequency) by the transformer (Tr). The signal detector (D) of the amplifier and the capacitor C are connected in series so that the signal by this current does not enter the amplifier (AMP). Therefore, the current flowing to the earth capacitances (CA, CB and CC) is bypassed to the capacitor (C) to avoid giving input signals to the amplifier (AMP), and the AC signal is not amplified. The DC content biases the lines of the phases (A, B and C) through the windings of the transformer (Tr) from the DC power supply (DC) installed in the device. If the insulation of the circuit is higher than a certain value (normal), the DCdoes not leak to the outside of the circuit, and DC current does not flow into the detector. As stated above, since this device is biased by DC, charging current flows to the capacitances (CA, CB and CC) only just after MCCB are closed even if the circuit is long and the earth capacitances (CA, CB and CC) are large. After this, it will stabilize, and DC will not flow. Therefore, even on a long circuit, it will not be affected by the earth capacitances (CA, CB and CC). Against transient inrush current generated when MCCB is closed, a special circuit for prohibiting operation is provided to prevent malfunction. Then, if the insulation at the point A of T phase has deteriorated and the insulation to the earth is degraded, DC current from the DC power supply will flow to the resistor  (R2), grounding point (E), fault point (A), transformer neutral point (N) and resistor (R1). After the completion of charging of the capacitor (C) connected in series with the detector (D), all DC current will flow to the detector (D), the signal of the detector (D) will be amplified by the amplifier (AMP), and insulation deterioration will be detected. With this device, insignificant decrease of circuit insulation to 400kW or less can be detected. The sensitivity can be switched in 6 stages, 10 – 20 – 50 – 100 – 200 – 400k.

Method by combining grounded capacitors and ELCB
Capacitors are connected to the secondary side of non grounded insulating transformer, the neutral point is grounded, and, when one-line ground occurs, ELCB detects the ground fault and protects the circuit.
(1) 3-phase 3-wire Non-grounded insulating transformers are generally Δconnected. The relationship between grounded capacitor capacity and ground fault current in this case is shown below.

Fig. 9. 32

 

Fig. 9. 33


In Fig. 9. 32, the capacitors with capacitances CA, CB and CC are star-connected, and the neutral point is grounded. This circuit is redrawn in Fig. 9. 33 to make it easier to understand the connection. In the normal state, the capacitors are a star-connected load consisting of capacitors when viewed from the power supply side, but, when a ground fault occurs, the resistance Rg (including the fault resistance of device, earth resistance of device and grounded resistance of capacitor) of the ground fault circuit is considered to be connected in series with the ground fault capacitor CA of phase A, and the current flowing to Rg is detected by the ZCT. On condition that the capacitor capacities of the phases are identical and CA = CB = CC = C, the relationship between capacitor capaci ty C and ground faul t cur rent Ig can be determined by the following formulas.

Fig. 9. 34

  Calculation method

At first, determine the maximum limit of ground fault current (related to the current sensitivity). The current should be about twice the rated current sensitivity of ELCB to be used. Therefore, the required capacitor capacity C can be obtained from the formula (2) by determining the maximum detected ground fault current, the current sensitivity, and
estimating the ground fault resistance Rg.

<Example>
Determine the capacitor capacity required to protect the circuit from ground fault with ELCB by grounding the capacitors as shown in Fig. 9. 34. The line voltage is 440V, frequency is 60Hz, and the total resistance Rg of the ground fault circuit is 150 Ohms. In this example, assume that ELCB with sensitivity of 200mA is used, and the ground fault current is 0.5A. From the formula (2), 
Therefore, if the capacitor capacity in Fig. 9. 34 is 1.8mF (actually, a capacitor with standard capacity of 2mF is used), current of 0.5A will flow when the grounded circuit resistance reduces to 150W, and the current sensitivity of 500mA is allowable. However, actually, the sensitivity is set to 200mA with a little margin for more reliable operation. If a highsensitivity circuit breaker is used, ground fault current can be detected even when the grounded circuit resistance is high. For example, when ELCB with sensitivity of 30mA is used, Rg can be determined by the formula (2) as shown below.
 
That is, when the grounded circuit resistance reduces to 8500W, ELCB operates and protects the circuit. This offers the advantage of detection of ground fault at an early stage at which the degree of fault is minor. After the capacitor capacity is determined, it is necessary to select a capacitor having a withstand voltage (rated voltage) appropriate to the circuit voltage. Although the voltage applied to the capacitor is V / 1.732 in the normal state, use a capacitor having two times higher withstand voltage to allow a margin. Since 44 / 1.732 _ 2 _ 509, use a 2-mF capacitor having the standard voltage of 600V.

(2) Single-phase 2-wire, neutral point grounding

Fig. 9. 35


From the formula (6), the required capacitor capacity can be obtained.

(3) 3-phase 3-wire (star connection)

 In the case of 3-phase, when the line voltage is V,
 
From the formula (8), the required capacitor capacity can be obtained.


4) Simplified calculation formula of capacitor capacitance
If the ground fault resistance Rg is negligible, the capacitor capacitance can be determined by the following simplified calculation formula. In the case of 3-phase 3-wire (Δ connection)



Quick chart of capacitor grounded capacity on nongrounded electric circuit for the purpose of detection of earth leakage


Fig. 9. 37-1


Example: To obtain a ground fault current of 200mA at ground fault resistance of 500W, the capacitor capacity shall be 3.5mF.
(The ground fault current shall be at least twice the rated current sensitivity.)


 
Fig. 9. 37-3


9. 7. 3 Method by grounding transformer
This method is designed to detect zero-phase voltage and break the circuit owing to ground fault. When the devices are connected as shown in Fig. 9. 38, the voltage applied to the primary winding is EA + EB + EC, and the corresponding voltage is induced to each phase of the secondary delta winding. The voltage applied to ^4 is the vectorial sum of the voltages of the phases, EA + EB + EC. From Fig. 9. 39, 
NA = EA + NE
NB = EB + NE
NC = EC + NE
The both sides of these formulas are added to obtain the following formula.
NA + NB􀊴 + NC = EA + EB + EC + 3EN
As is evidenced from Fig. 9. 39, N is the center of the triangle, and the left side is 0. Therefore, 
EA + EB + EC = −3NE = 3EN
Since EN is zero-phase voltage, three times larger zerophase voltage appears in ^4. This voltage is detected, and the voltage relay is operated to trip the circuit breaker to protect the circuit from ground fault.
 
Fig. 9. 38

 
Fig. 9. 39

 9. 7. 4 Method by grounding detector
This method is similar to the method stated in (2) “grounding transformer.” The degree of ground fault and the grounding phase can be defined by the indicator. Fig. 9. 40 shows the connection diagram of model LM-11NGD grounding detector

Fig. 9. 40


 


No comments:

Post a Comment

Medium-Voltage Distribution System Design

A. Single Bus, Figure 1.1-40 The sources (utility and/or generator(s)) are connected to a single bus. All feeders are connected to the ...